Skip to main content
82 / 100

When it comes to home repairs and improvements, many homeowners find themselves facing the dilemma of whether to tackle the project themselves or hire a handyman. While hiring a handyman can be a convenient solution, it’s essential to consider various factors before making that decision. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of hiring a handyman and provide you with valuable insights to help you make an informed choice for your home improvement needs.

Pros of Hiring a Handyman

Time-Saving: One of the most significant advantages of hiring a handyman is the time you save. They are experienced professionals who can complete tasks quickly and efficiently, allowing you to focus on other aspects of your life.

Skill and Expertise: Handymen are skilled in various trades, from plumbing and electrical work to carpentry and general maintenance. Their expertise ensures that your project is done correctly and up to code.

Convenience: Handyman services are often available on short notice, making them a convenient option for urgent repairs or tasks you simply don’t have the time or skill to handle.

Cost-Efficient: Hiring a handyman for multiple small tasks or repairs can be more cost-effective than hiring individual specialists for each job. They often charge by the hour or provide a package deal for multiple tasks.

Tools and Equipment: Handymen typically bring their tools and equipment, saving you the expense and hassle of purchasing specialized tools for a one-time project.

Safety: Some home repairs and maintenance tasks can be dangerous if not done correctly. Handymen are trained to work safely, reducing the risk of accidents or injuries.

Cons of Hiring a Handyman


Cost: While hiring a handyman can be cost-effective for smaller tasks, their hourly rates may add up for more extensive projects. It’s essential to get a clear estimate and discuss costs upfront.

Limited Specialization: Handymen are versatile, but they may lack the expertise required for highly specialized tasks, such as major electrical or plumbing work. For such projects, you might need to hire a specialist.

Quality Variability: The quality of work can vary among handymen. It’s crucial to research and choose a reputable handyman or handyman service with positive reviews and references.

Scheduling Challenges: Depending on their availability, handymen may not always align with your schedule, potentially causing delays in your project.

Lack of Licensing and Insurance: Not all handymen are licensed or insured. For certain jobs, especially those involving electrical or plumbing work, it’s crucial to ensure the handyman has the necessary qualifications.

Communication Issues: Effective communication is key to a successful project. Some handymen may struggle with communication, leading to misunderstandings or mismanaged expectations.

When to Hire a Handyman

Small Repairs: If you have a list of small repairs and maintenance tasks, such as fixing a leaky faucet, repairing a door, or patching up drywall, hiring a handyman is an excellent choice.

Time Constraints: When you’re pressed for time and need a project completed quickly, a handyman can step in and get the job done without much delay.

Non-Specialized Tasks: Handymen are ideal for tasks that don’t require specialized expertise, such as installing shelves, assembling furniture, or painting rooms.

Budget-Friendly: If you’re working with a tight budget, a handyman can often offer cost-effective solutions for your home improvement needs.

General Maintenance: Routine maintenance tasks like gutter cleaning, lawn care, and general home upkeep can be efficiently handled by a handyman.

Multiple Small Projects: If you have a variety of small projects around your home, hiring a handyman to tackle them all at once can save you time and money.

When to Consider Specialists

Electrical or Plumbing Work: For any electrical or plumbing work, it’s crucial to hire licensed professionals who have the expertise to ensure safety and compliance with local codes.

Major Renovations: Extensive home renovations, such as kitchen remodels or room additions, are best left to specialized contractors who can manage the project from start to finish.

Structural Repairs: If you suspect structural issues in your home, consult with a structural engineer or specialist to assess the problem and develop a comprehensive repair plan.

Permits and Inspections: For projects requiring permits and inspections, it’s essential to hire contractors who are familiar with the local regulations and can ensure compliance.

Health and Safety Concerns: When dealing with hazardous materials like asbestos or mold, or projects with potential safety risks, it’s advisable to consult specialists.

Custom Carpentry or Fine Detail Work: Projects that demand exceptional craftsmanship, like custom cabinetry or intricate woodwork, are better suited for skilled carpenters or artisans.

Tips for Hiring a Handyman

Research: Look for recommendations from friends, family, or online reviews to find a reliable handyman. Check for proper licensing and insurance as well.

Get Multiple Quotes: Obtain quotes from several handymen to compare costs and services. Be sure to get a detailed breakdown of the work and materials involved.

Ask for References: Request references from past clients to gauge the handyman’s work quality and reliability.

Discuss Expectations: Clearly communicate your expectations, project timeline, and budget with the handyman to avoid misunderstandings.

Get It in Writing: Always have a written agreement that outlines the scope of work, cost, payment schedule, and any warranties offered.

Check for Permits: For projects requiring permits, ensure the handyman is knowledgeable about the permitting process and will handle it accordingly.

Inspect the Work: After the project is completed, inspect the work thoroughly to ensure it meets your expectations and quality standards.

Average Handyman Services Cost Per Job

Below, we’ve compiled a comprehensive list of services and their respective average costs, offering a glimpse into the investment you might expect for each task.

Please note that these figures are average and may vary depending on your location, the complexity of the project, and the specific handyman you choose to hire. 

Services Ranges from  Ranges to 
Average cost to repair doors $175 $300
Average cost to repair decks $450 $1800
Average cost to repair drywall hole $80 $520
Average cost to assemble furniture $100 $350
Average cost to install air conditioner $175 $225
Average cost install to bathroom accessories $45 $175
Average cost to mount a TV on a wall $120 $250
Average cost to install shelves $65 $120
Average cost to paint walls $400 $4000
Average cost to repair kitchen sink $200 $300
Average cost to replace toilet $200 $300
Average cost to repair tile (1) $75 $200

Hiring a handyman like Odd Job Handyman Services can be a convenient and cost-effective solution for a wide range of home repairs and maintenance tasks. However, it’s crucial to carefully consider the scope of your project, your budget, and the specific skills required before making a decision. For more specialized or complex projects, consulting with licensed professionals is often the safest and most reliable choice. Ultimately, by weighing the pros and cons and following best practices when hiring a handyman, you can ensure that your home improvement projects are successful and hassle-free.